Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Reviewing Books Of Poetry

I like to read poetry, as many of you know, and I also like to write reviews of lots of things, as you can probably tell by the 300+ reviews I've done for this blog, but reviewing poetry books is kind of a mixed bag for me. One problem is that everybody expects when a poet reviews a book of poetry that they try to make their review sound poetic, but fuck all that noise, and also I don't like sounding academic which everybody also wants you to do, to which I say balls poopy vaghole. The biggest problem though is that in this world of google alerts, I always worry that if I write a bad review of somebody's book their feelings will get hurt. When I half-jokingly reviewed Fence Magazine a while back, somebody obviously got angry and started crying or something, and I felt a little regretful because I don't want to make anybody feel bad with this blog, but rather I want them to laugh or some other such joyous act. However, I believe there is a serious lack of poetry police out there, though, and that a lot of journals don't want to publish negative reviews because it "hurts poetry" or maybe for the same sappy reasons I am reluctant to do it. But without poetry police actually leveling legitimate criticism, who's going to call out bad books and bad poetic directions? I don't think I'm alone in saying the majority of American poetry being published in major literary journals is bland and highly predictable. Hey, maybe cantankerous old Yvor Winters had the right idea. In conclusion I would like to say poopy again, and also you probably shouldn't come to this blog for legitimate academic criticism, and if I hurt your feelings somehow I am sorry in advance.

RATING: 27%

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

You know, Fence magazine really is the best journal in the business! You'd be lucky to be published there. =*****************************************(

Anonymous said...

I would add that what you previously posted was not a review at all. And you're right, you sounded neither poetic (as in, I'm interested in language) or academic (as in, I understand the definition of analysis). Why blog, if you're only sharing opinions that you don't consider "legitimate"?

Jacqui said...

Wow. Somebody needs to chill.

Anonymous said...

Ohhh! Quash!!

DCP said...

Well this is obviously a comedy blog is why blog. I reviewed a banana I found on the ground the other day for God's sake. Too many people don't know what humor is. Might I direct you to the hilarious new Mike Myers movie "The Love Guru?"

Bryan said...

I am extraordinarily confused as to why "anonymous" is reading this blog at all. I'm going to guess Glenn's aforementioned Google Alerts.

laurie said...

You know, I may have sold out on being an artist, but at least I'm not some whiny little poetry bitch trolling around peoples blogs boo hooing because somebody doesn't like a thing that I like. booooohoooo. Stick it up your ass anon, because sometimes people will disagree with you. And you can either come back with a well argued rebuttal or you can bitch and moan and attack my friends, who will then laugh at you.

LoCo said...

Weird. I would think Fence would know all about the joys and virtues of spreading one's acerbic opinions via blog.

John said...

Anonymous, where have you been all my life? If you thought that was bad, you should read what Glenn wrote about Pan's Labyrinth. Marry me, ma cherie, and let's live together on a Canadian polygamous compound.

John said...

Gay marriage is cool up here, too, just in case you're an anonymous dude.

Bryan said...

Be careful, John. We have no proof that the anonymous poster has a sense of humor. You could wake up tomorrow with a faceless, nameless husbandwife.

Anonymous said...

Drams!

Also, the only thing worse than poetry is poets.

LoCo said...

And, the only thing worse than poets is Albany. No hard feelings!

Chris said...

Wow. Of all the reviews this gets the most comments. I didn't know poetry was even popular.

laurie said...

I think it's an illusion caused by the fact that we have like half of America's poets right here.

Anonymous said...

The good half.