Showing posts with label watchmen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label watchmen. Show all posts

Sunday, May 24, 2009

Tales of the Black Freighter

The animated title feature is gorily true to the comic but doesn't amount to much of a story on its own. Under the Hood was so boring that I spent most of its run time trying to decide whether or not I should turn it off. Both belong on a special edition Watchmen DVD, not a $20 stand alone release. Between this, David Hayter's whining letter to fans, and the reputed squidless ending, the Watchmen movie is getting on my nerves and I haven't even seen it yet. I fucking hate Hollywood.

RATING: 25%

(Image from slashfilm.com.)

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Watchmen (2009 Film)

As mentioned, after rereading the graphic novel Watchmen I believed it was unfilmable, and went into the movie version thinking it would be awful. It turns out it wasn't awful, but it wasn't particularly good either. It's amazing how much of the book they managed to cram into 160 minutes, but the seriousness of the work's deconstruction of the Superhero and its psychoanalysis of its characters is diminished by out of place graphic violence lingered on in loving slow-motion and even more out of place music, both of which added a level of jokiness that seemed to suggest that Visionary Director Zack Snyder felt he was superior to the whole fiasco. Maybe if I wasn't so familiar with the source material than I would have felt it was better, but at least Rorschach was terrific, and Night Owl and The Comedian were pretty spot on, too.

RATING: 62%

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Watchmen

To prep myself for the upcoming movie version I decided to reread this book to see if it was as good as I remember, and of course it was. The art is amazing, misogynist Alan Moore's writing is at it's most psychologically complex, and the social relevance to 1980s American jingoism and the reworking of the superhero genre as a whole is as intricate and emotionally powerful as any regular novel could hope to be (disclaimer: I don't read regular novels). One downfall is I'm reassured that it is unfilmable, and looking at Alan Moore's graphic novel-to-movie history, in addition to "visionary" Zack Snyder's resume, I'm doubtful this movie will be anything but a three hour mess. Oh well, the movie's existence doesn't negate the graphic novel's existence, and at least it will bring a whole new audience to what is the third best graphic novel of all time.

RATING: 98%

(As Bryan would say, alternate ending here.)

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Watchmen

After watching the Watchmen movie trailer about 200 times, I got kinda tired of it and figured I'd go back and read Alan Moore's graphic novel again. A lot of people say it's overrated, but then again, a lot of people (especially white people) are inbred. Watchmen is a 20th Century classic, and there are lots of pictures, so Glenn can read it.

RATING: 92%


(Image from www.ebooknetworking.com)